Disclaimer: this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Buy a signed shirt primarily because you love it, not as an investment.
The question comes up regularly: 'Is a signed shirt also a good investment?' The answer is nuanced. Yes, some shirts increase significantly in value. No, it is not a guarantee. And: it depends on many factors that are not always predictable.
When does a signed shirt increase in value?
The value of signed memorabilia is determined by a combination of factors. The most important:
- The fame of the player: Shirts from absolute global superstars — a Cruijff, a Pelé, a Maradona — are rarer and more valuable than shirts from players who have less iconic status.
- Rarity: Is it a World Cup shirt? A shirt from a historic match? The rarer the shirt, the more the signature is worth.
- Authenticity: A shirt without a COA is worth hardly anything on the secondary market. A shirt with documented visual material of the signing session is worth considerably more.
- Condition: Damage to the shirt or the signature reduces the value. Store it properly, preferably framed.
Historical examples
A signed shirt from Johan Cruijff may have been worth €200 twenty years ago. After his death in 2016 and its continued cultural relevance, prices rose sharply. Authentically certified shirts from Cruijff now regularly fetch €1,500 to €3,000 at auctions.
But this is an exceptional case. Most shirts increase moderately in value, if they increase at all.
When is it NOT a good investment?
- If the player has little cultural significance outside their own fanbase
- If the shirt has no documented provenance (no COA, no photo)
- If you buy the shirt from an unreliable seller
- If you expect a quick return
Our recommendation
Buy a signed shirt because it moves you. Because it is a connection to a moment, a player, a memory. The financial value is a bonus — not a guarantee. If you take that as your starting point, you will always be satisfied with your purchase.
And if the value has doubled in 20 years? A nice bonus.