How can you spot a fake signed football shirt?

The market for signed football shirts is large — and unfortunately also filled with fakes. Online auctions, Marktplaats ads and social media are full of shirts that are 'signed' by legends such as Cruijff, Ronaldo or Messi, but where the authenticity is questionable at best. How do you recognize a fake shirt? And how can you be sure you are buying the real thing?

1. No COA = major red flag

A Certificate of Authenticity (COA) is the minimum documentation that should accompany an authentic signed shirt. A COA states at least: the player's name, the date of the signing session, the name of the organizing party, and a unique serial number or QR code with which you can verify the authenticity. Does a seller not have a COA? Then do not proceed.

2. No proof of the session = unverifiable

A COA alone is not enough — many fake COAs also exist. Always ask for photo or video proof of the actual signing session. This can be a photo of the player signing the shirt, or a video of the moment. At 4S Signed Shirts, we have both for every shirt in our collection.

3. A 'too good' signature

Real signatures from athletes are quickly, dynamically and sometimes sloppily applied in practice. They also change over the years. Many fakes are precisely too accurate or too 'perfect'. Always compare the signature with known, verified examples from the same player.

4. The price is too low

An authentic signed shirt from a recognized legend costs hundreds of euros — not tens. A Cruijff shirt for €50 on Marktplaats is 99% likely to be fake. Prices at reliable sellers like 4S Signed Shirts are always in line with the market value. Cheap is expensive.

5. The seller cannot be traced

Never buy from an anonymous seller. A reliable seller has a recognizable name, a website, customer reviews, and is available for questions. At 4S Signed Shirts, you work directly with us via WhatsApp. We are transparent about every session and every shirt.

How does 4S Signed Shirts buy its shirts?

All shirts in our collection are signed during official sessions, facilitated by Numero14 — the most renowned signing session organizer in Europe. Numero14 works exclusively with professional athletes in a controlled environment. Each shirt receives a COA with a unique number. In addition, we have photo and video proof of every session.

Doubts? Ask us

If you see a shirt somewhere and doubt whether it is real, send us a WhatsApp. We are happy to help you assess whether an offer is reliable — even if you do not buy it from us. Authenticity in the market for signed shirts is in everyone's best interest. View our certified collection.

Back to blog