How to spot a fake signed football shirt: 7 warning signs

The market for signed football shirts is growing rapidly. Unfortunately, so is the supply of counterfeit products. Whether you want to buy a shirt from Johan Cruijff, Patrick Kluivert, or Clarence Seedorf, without the right knowledge you run the risk of purchasing a fake.

In this article, you will learn the 7 most common warning signs — so you will never be deceived.

1. No certificate of authenticity (COA)

A legitimate signed shirt always comes with an official Certificate of Authenticity (COA). This certificate contains the player's name, the date of the signing session, and a unique serial number. Sellers who cannot provide a COA have something to hide.

At 4S Signed Shirts, every buyer receives an official COA with their shirt. No exceptions.

2. No photo or video evidence of the signing session

A signature on paper proves nothing. What does provide proof is a photo or video of the moment the player actually signs the shirt. We work with Numero14, a specialized organization that facilitates signing sessions with professional photo and video documentation.

3. The price is too good to be true

An authentic signed shirt from Johan Cruijff can easily cost between €1,500 and €3,000. If someone offers the same shirt for €150, the chance of it being a fake is almost 100%. Compare prices from reputable auction houses as a reference.

4. The signature looks too perfect

Real signatures are never perfectly identical. A player signs thousands of shirts — each signature has small variations. A fake is often too regular, too neat, or has lines that are too thin. Always compare with well-known certified examples.

5. The seller cannot be traced

Reliable sellers have a verifiable reputation, a physical address, and contact details. Anonymous sellers on Marktplaats or Facebook Marketplace are a major risk. 4S Signed Shirts is located in Bathmen, the Netherlands, and can be reached directly via WhatsApp on 06-11193163.

6. The shirt is historically incorrect

Always check whether the shirt matches the time period of the signature. A shirt from the 1974 World Cup with a modern polyester finish is almost certainly fake. Verify the badge, sponsor, material, and manufacturing details.

7. No reputation or reviews

Look for reviews from real buyers. A reliable seller has a track record of satisfied customers and is active on social media with photos from real signing sessions.

Conclusion: only buy from certified suppliers

At 4S Signed Shirts, we guarantee: ✓ Official COA with every shirt · ✓ Photo and video evidence of every signing session · ✓ Partnership with Numero14 · ✓ Transparent pricing · ✓ Personal contact via WhatsApp: 06-11193163

View our full collection of signed shirts and buy with confidence.

Back to blog